We actually discussed this during our alpha phase some months ago. There were a few reasons why we decided against it in the end:
It’s a manual whitelist of emoji to set up in the admin page (discourse_reactions_enabled_reactions)
If we want to be inclusive, we have to create a very large list of emoji for skin tones (or use the blue-skin ones as Fedora does)
It dilutes the value of the Like - for example, that other reactions are not included in your Cheers score, and queries around top-likers etc are less easy to arrange
1 & 2 are manageable, but 3 bothers me as a data person. So my first question would be - which emoji would you want to be able to choose from? I am reminded of the Paradox forums, which have only “Agree” and “Respectfully disagree”
3 does irk me, I just got excited when I saw it was a plugin, and didn’t know about the backend management and data implications.
So used to discord where I can add 20 reactions to something and the points don’t matter.
I agree, reactions are a standard. But this is not chat, and I don’t want it to become chat either
It’s also easy to dismiss the scores and gamification stuff, but we do want to do a better job of recognising work done, especially where that isn’t code (because counting GitHub is relatively easy)